Originally Posted by
cmurdur
I'm not denying anything. You and I have seen only two minutes of the film, with the special effects more than likely unfinished at this point, and I liked it. I never said that the movie will be great. You've already established that you know the movie will be garbage. You're upset because Haley isn't acting exactly like Robert and even more so that it isn't Robert. There are eight movies with Englund as the star. Go watch those if you're going to cry about this one. If you can't accept anyone else playing the role, then you're just an idiot.
You, like many other people, want to cover their eyes and ears because it's not staring the man who he himself has said he has no problem not doing the part anymore. So many people have cried out for a new movie that takes it back to the original roots of Freddy in the shadows as the ultimate sadist and that's what they're fucking doing. But no, that's not good enough. You want same old thing. You want Robert to play the role forever and let no one else ever come close to touching the role. Which is robbery to us fans who love the character. You can appreciate Robert all you want, but thinking that only he can ever play the role is horseshit.
How do you know that Haley isn't going to add on to role, doing something that Robert never thought of? The lips seemed to be burned off, which is probably a decision made by Haley and not Brad Fuller. A lot of people said two years ago the exact same shit that's being said now about Heath Ledger and the Joker. I heard so many times that Ledger was going to suck, Jack was the best Joker ever, and no one could ever come close to touching his Godlike performance. And how did that work out?
Haley could be bad in this role and this movie could suck, but saying that it is going to be terrible is retarded. All judgment of that kind should be reserved until you actually fucking see it. It's ok to say you think it's going to be bad because you don't like the cast, the director, the script, etc, but not because the apparent Jesus Christ of horror movie actors isn't in it. This movie is being trashed and hated off of a two minute trailer alone and yet not one person who claims that it's going to suck has even seen the movie.
You can cry and boo-hoo all you want Robert purists, but I'm not going to give a shit about your opinion until you accept and realize that the movie is going to star Jackie Earle Haley, not Robert Englund, and just because Haley is not some clone of Englund, that his portrayal of the character is not going to suck.